Scott McGeever
As the market softens, more buyers’ agents are hearing from clients unhappy with a valuation, whether it’s for the property they’re trying to buy or one they want to refinance. Often the frustration comes from a common misunderstanding about how valuations work.
Many buyers’ agent clients assume a valuer has some flexibility on the final figure, and that it can be nudged up to match their expectations.
In reality, registered valuers work under a strict set of guidelines. Whatever figure they reach must be founded on and supported by evidence that meets specific criteria. Valuers are also legally liable for both their assessment and their commentary. If the evidence doesn’t support a higher number, the valuer can’t give one.
While it’s extremely rare for valuations to come in under contract price in a regular, fair, open-market negotiation with no extenuating circumstances, that possibility always exists. In fact, if the market continues to soften, the probability of below-contract-price assessments probably increases.
Understanding how valuers work in a shifting market helps you manage client expectations before the report arrives, so I wanted to explore a few elements of the valuation process and how registered property valuers handle markets like the one we’ve experienced this year.
Only recent evidence counts
When conditions change as quickly as they have this year, valuers have fewer sales they can rely on. In the current market, one clear approach is to use only sales made since the 12 May Federal Budget. Earlier sales reflect conditions that no longer exist.
When doing an assessment, the valuers will need to assume a short sales campaign of three to four weeks at most to reach a definite result. There’s no hanging about waiting for the market to bounce back. They must assess a figure as at the date of inspection under those market conditions.
Where a value range is given, expect it to be tight as the market drops. A spread of about 5%, such as $950,000 to $1 million for a $975,000 mid-position single figure. Alternatively, the bottom of the range may simply be lowered to reflect the softening conditions.
Facts, not headlines
In a shifting market, conversations with selling agents matter more. A good valuer will speak with a broad range of agents in their area, and with other specialists (including fellow valuers where suitable).
Some data-driven commentary can be useful. General media speculation, though, should ideally carry no weight whatsoever. Valuers will rely only on facts they can easily check.
If a contract price looks “toppish”, can a valuer accept it anyway? Ultimately yes, but only within what the evidence supports, and the report would always explain why the price seemed high. Also, in today’s market especially, any value range would still be held to that tight 5% spread.
Closing the gap in sales evidence
Sales evidence lags the market, but the delay is shorter than many people assume. Most valuation firms keep an up-to-date database of recent sales, and settled sales now appear on data platforms fairly quickly. Valuers who specialise in an area generally know what’s on the market and what’s selling.
Lenders are also sensitive to market shifts. In almost every circumstance, lenders will only rely on valuations where the date of assessment is no more than 90 days old. If there is any flexibility, it will only be where the borrower has an extremely low LVR, and the lender wants to avoid the cost of an updated valuation. This has implications for clients who get pre-approved finance but then take a long time to contract on a property.
One other thing, the figure isn’t the only thing a financier reads. I alluded to risk ratings earlier. These scores, provided by the valuer, explain elements of risk particular to the property and its surroundings, and they can influence a “yes/no” lending decision just as much as the assessed figure.
Valuation dispute
Clients may ask you to challenge a valuation, but that’s never an easy process. If your client has settled sales evidence the valuer didn’t include or didn’t know about, they can give it to the lender and ask for it to be considered. The other option is to request a second valuation. Both of these paths are, however, at the lender’s discretion, and neither is likely to be considered for a high-LVR loan.
Buyer’s agents often have to navigate tough conversations, but the best strategy is to talk to your clients early and realistically about the process and possibilities. Explain that valuations will rely on post-Budget evidence, sit within a tight range and may come in below the contract price in some circumstances. That conversation now can save a much harder one later.
Scott McGeever is a registered property valuer and licensed real estate agent in Queensland and New South Wales. He is a founding member and Life Member of REBAA, and has served as the association’s Vice President, President and Queensland State Representative. In 1999, he became the first registered valuer in Queensland to offer a full buyers’ agency service when he co-founded Property Searchers in Brisbane.